These offences are found in the Companies Act 1967 (“CA”). We refer to them as directors’ offences because directors are the people most often charged with them, although several are not limited to directors. See our page on directors’ offences and their punishment for a full breakdown and explanation of these offences.
What must the Prosecution prove for each offence?
- Failing to act honestly or to use reasonable diligence (section 157(1) of the CA). A director must “at all times act honestly and use reasonable diligence in the discharge of the duties of his or her office”. The High Court has drawn a sharp distinction between two kinds of directors. On the one hand is a director who is involved in the company’s affairs but makes a negligent error in discharging his or her duties – an isolated negligent breach of that kind may not call for imprisonment. On the other hand is a director who takes up a directorship but knowingly turns a blind eye to the company’s affairs. In Public Prosecutor v Zheng Jia [2025] 3 SLR 1290, the director was a chartered accountant whose business was to register himself as the locally resident director of companies incorporated for foreign clients, while exercising no control or supervision over them. The court held that this was not a case of mere neglect: the director had every intention of neglecting the duty from the outset, despite knowing the risk that the companies could be abused, and directors who take office with every intention of abdicating their duty are acting knowingly, if not intentionally. This goes to how blameworthy the director is, and therefore to sentence. See our page on the risks of being a nominee director.
- Improper use of position or information (section 157(2) of the CA). The Prosecution must prove (1) that the accused was an officer or agent of the company; and (2) that he or she made improper use of that position, or of information obtained through it, to gain an advantage, directly or indirectly, for himself or herself or for any other person, or to cause detriment to the company.
- Acting as a director while disqualified (section 154(5) of the CA). The Prosecution must prove (1) that the accused was disqualified, either automatically following a conviction or by a court order; and (2) that during the period of disqualification he or she acted as a director of a company, or took part, directly or indirectly, in its management, without the court’s permission (section 154(3) of the CA).
What defences are available?
The possible defences for each of the offences discussed above are as follows:
-
Failing to act honestly or to use reasonable diligence (section 157(1) of the CA).
-
Reliance on others. Section 157C of the CA allows a director, in exercising powers or performing duties, to rely on reports, financial data and professional advice from others. These include employees whom he or she believes on reasonable grounds to be reliable and competent; professional advisers and experts; and other directors, or committees of directors, on matters within their authority. The director must have relied on them in good faith, after making proper inquiry where the circumstances indicated the need for it, and without knowing that the reliance was unwarranted (section 157C(2) of the CA). This may be relevant where a director of a genuine business is said to have failed to use reasonable diligence. It does not assist a nominee director who, by agreement, took no part in the company’s affairs:
-
in Public Prosecutor v Liew Sze Hui [2025] SGMC 60, the director had signed a “Nominee Non-Executive Director Agreement” stating that she would not be involved in the company’s financial or business matters;
-
the court held that this was not a negligent error but an intention from the outset to abandon the duty; and
-
far from assisting her, the agreement implicated her. The court treated it as formalising her complete abdication of the duty, which counted against her as an offence-specific factor under the Zheng Jia framework, and as showing that she had taken up the appointment with every intention of abdicating the duty. That is the kind of director whom the High Court has described as acting knowingly, if not intentionally.
-
-
Challenging the elements. The accused may dispute what the director’s duties required in the circumstances of the particular company, and whether he or she in fact failed to act honestly or to use reasonable diligence in discharging them.
-
-
Improper use of position or information (section 157(2) of the CA). There is no specific statutory defence. The accused may challenge the elements, for example by disputing that he or she made use of the position or information, or that the use made of it was improper, or that it was made to gain an advantage or to cause detriment to the company.
-
Acting as a director while disqualified (section 154(5) of the CA). There is no specific statutory defence. The accused may dispute that he or she was disqualified at the time, or that what he or she did amounted to acting as a director or taking part in the company’s management, or show that the court had given permission to act (section 154(6) of the CA).