For a full explanation of sentencing in directors’ offences, see our page on how the courts sentence directors’ offences. We refer to the offences discussed on these pages as directors’ offences because directors are the people most often charged with them, although several are not limited to directors.

What can reduce the sentence?

The following have been given weight in decided cases:

  • Smaller personal gain. In Ng Kuan Chuan v Public Prosecutor [2026] SGHC 5, the brokerage director’s smaller personal gain (US$300,000) justified a sentence six months below the founder’s, even though his part in operating the trades was pivotal.
  • Smaller scale. In the same appeal, the High Court reduced both sentences after comparing the scheme with an earlier scheme (Phang Wah v Public Prosecutor [2012] 1 SLR 646) that was larger in scale and in the personal gain received (about US$5.1 million). This was so even though one factor pointed the other way: the investors in this scheme had lost about US$13.7 million, whereas in the earlier case no participant appeared to have been adversely affected. The court nonetheless held that, given the greater scale and reach of the earlier scheme and the slightly greater personal gain of its operator, the sentence should not exceed the four and a half years imposed in that case.
  • Fewer offence-specific factors. Under the framework in Public Prosecutor v Zheng Jia [2025] 3 SLR 1290 (“Zheng Jia”), the number and gravity of the offence-specific factors determine the band. What the director did to check the company and monitor its accounts, and how quickly he or she acted when warning signs appeared, are therefore central.
  • Showing that imprisonment is not warranted. Because imprisonment is presumptive for nominee directors, the director bears the burden of showing why it should not be imposed. This is a matter for submissions on sentence, supported by evidence of what the director did (or did not do).
  • A plea of guilty. In Zheng Jia and in Public Prosecutor v Liew Sze Hui [2025] SGMC 60, credit was given for the plea of guilty.

Not every point raised in mitigation carries weight. In Liew Sze Hui, four points were raised: the short duration of the directorship, the absence of personal benefit, the fact that the business model was the offender’s husband’s, and her remorse. They were held not to detract from her complete abandonment of the duty and her active role in moving the money.

An example. In Liew Sze Hui, the Prosecution sought three and a half months’ imprisonment and the defence a fine. The court held that the case called for imprisonment under the Zheng Jia framework, but imposed three months, below the Prosecution’s position. The difference lay in how the offence-specific factors were taken into account. The Prosecution placed the case in Band 2, with a starting point of five months. The court found three offence-specific factors fully present, but treated the director’s knowledge of the risk of abuse as only half a factor, because her culpability (i.e., blameworthiness) on that score was engaged only once the authorities had begun investigating another of her husband’s companies. With three and a half factors, it placed the case between Bands 1 and 2, with a starting point of four and a half months, and then reduced it by 30% for her early plea of guilty, arriving at three months.

As the cases show, the outcome depends heavily on identifying the mitigating factors that are relevant and carry real weight on the particular facts, supporting them with evidence, and presenting them at the right stage of the sentencing process.

How does a plea of guilty affect the sentence?

A plea of guilty can have a significant effect on the sentence, and its timing matters. The Sentencing Advisory Panel has issued Guidelines on Reduction in Sentences for Guilty Pleas, which suggest that an earlier plea may attract a larger reduction. The guidelines are guidance only: they are not binding on the courts, and whether a reduction is given, and how much, is for the sentencing court to decide in the circumstances of each case.

In Zheng Jia, credit was given for the pleas of guilty, weighed against a charge taken into consideration (i.e., a further charge which the offender admits and agrees may be taken into account in sentencing, instead of being tried separately). In Liew Sze Hui, the offender pleaded guilty and received three months, which is materially lower (by about 14%) than the three and a half months sought by the Prosecution.

A plea of guilty admits the offence and gives up any defence. It is therefore very important that the decision whether, and when, to plead guilty is made only after the evidence, the available defences and the mitigating factors have been properly assessed.

How are sentences combined when there are multiple charges?

Cases involving directors’ offences often involve several charges. Each charge receives its own sentence, and the court then decides which sentences run consecutively (one after another) and which run concurrently (at the same time). Where an offender is convicted at one trial and sentenced to imprisonment for three or more distinct offences, at least two of the sentences must run consecutively (section 307(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010). For example, fraudulent trading charges are often brought together with cheating charges for individual victims, securities charges and multi-level marketing charges; and nominee directors often face a separate charge for each company.

The overriding principle is proportionality: the total sentence must fit the offender’s overall criminality. The High Court has explained the main tools in Mohamed Shouffee bin Adam v Public Prosecutor [2014] 2 SLR 998:

  • The one-transaction rule. This is a common law principle, developed by the courts rather than set out in legislation: offences that form part of a single transaction should generally not attract consecutive sentences. Whether offences form part of a single transaction is decided as a matter of common sense, having regard to factors such as how close the offences were in time, place and purpose, and whether they invaded the same legally protected interest. In Ng Kuan Chuan, the sentence for the multi-level marketing charge ran consecutively with the fraudulent trading sentence, because the two offences protect different interests.
  • The totality principle. The court takes a “last look” at the total. It asks whether the total is substantially above the normal level of sentence for the most serious offence, and whether it would be crushing and out of keeping with the offender’s record and prospects. If so, the court may change which sentences run consecutively, or adjust individual sentences. In Zheng Jia, the individual sentences were moderated because they were to run consecutively.
  • No double counting. The same aggravating factor must not be counted against the offender twice.

The charges proceeded with have a large effect on the total. In a 2025 District Court decision (Public Prosecutor v Ng Swee Khiang [2025] SGDC 207), the fraudulent trading charge attracted 24 months’ imprisonment, but with 19 charges of conspiring to cheat investors and a charge of falsifying accounts, the total sentence was 80 months.

Parity and consistency with past cases

Proportionality is also measured against the sentences imposed on others:

  • Parity between co-offenders. Where several people took part in the same criminal enterprise, their sentences should generally be in line with each other, allowing for relevant differences in their roles and personal circumstances. The High Court has held (Lim Bee Ngan Karen v Public Prosecutor [2015] 4 SLR 1120) that this applies even where co-offenders are charged with different offences, and that where co-offenders are sentenced separately, the Prosecution should place their sentences and the relevant facts before the court. In Ng Kuan Chuan, the six-month difference between the sentences of the founder and the brokerage director reflected the difference in their personal gain.
  • Consistency with past cases. Courts compare the case with sentences imposed in similar cases for the same offence. In the same appeal, the High Court reduced sentences of six and a half years after comparing the scheme with earlier fraudulent trading cases, including one in which four and a half years had been imposed for a much larger scheme.

Other choices also affect the total, such as whether some charges are taken into consideration (i.e., further charges which the offender admits and agrees may be taken into account in sentencing, instead of being tried separately) rather than proceeded with, and whether conduct is combined into a single amalgamated charge (i.e., one charge covering several incidents of the same offence, which doubles the maximum punishment; see our page on amalgamated charges). These questions involve a number of factors and judgments, and are frequently the subject of submissions on sentence.