These offences are found in the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (“IRDA”). We refer to them as directors’ offences because directors are the people most often charged with them, although several are not limited to directors. Fraudulent trading and wrongful trading can be committed by anyone who is a party to the company’s business being carried on in that way, and the other offences apply to officers of the company and, in some cases, its contributories (e.g., shareholders). Fraudulent trading is included here because it is in the IRDA, but it does not require the company to be insolvent or wound up (see below). See our page on directors’ offences and their punishment for a full breakdown and explanation of these offences.

What must the Prosecution prove for each offence?

  • Fraudulent trading (section 238(4) of the IRDA). The Prosecution must prove:

    • (1) that the business of the company was carried on with intent to defraud creditors (of the company or of any other person), or for any fraudulent purpose; and

    • (2) that the accused was knowingly a party to carrying it on in that way.

    • Note: Fraudulent trading does not require a winding up, or that the victims be creditors. The offence can be committed whether or not the company has been, or is being, wound up (section 238(5) of the IRDA). The words “for any fraudulent purpose” are not limited to frauds on creditors. In a 2022 High Court decision (Lim Jun Yao Clarence v Public Prosecutor [2023] 3 SLR 862), the victims were some 1,317 foreign jobseekers who had paid fees for non-existent jobs. The High Court rejected the argument that the offence could not be committed because they were not creditors of the companies used.

  • Wrongful trading (section 239(6) of the IRDA). The Prosecution must prove (1) that the company incurred debts while insolvent, without a reasonable prospect of paying them (or became insolvent as a result of incurring debts without a reasonable prospect of paying them in full: section 239(12) of the IRDA); (2) that the accused was a party to this; and (3) that the accused knew this or, in the case of an officer, was in circumstances where he or she ought to have known.

  • Insolvency-related offences (sections 234, 236 and 237 of the IRDA). These apply where the company is, or comes to be, in judicial management or liquidation (or, for section 237, under investigation). The elements of each offence are as follows:

    • Section 234 (officers of companies in judicial management or liquidation). The Prosecution must prove (1) that the accused is a past or present officer, or a contributory (e.g., a shareholder), of a company that is in judicial management or is being wound up; and (2) that he or she did one of the following acts listed in section 234(1). These acts are:

      • failing to disclose fully and truly to the judicial manager or liquidator all the company’s property, and how, to whom, for what consideration and when any of it was disposed of (section 234(1)(a));

      • failing to deliver up to the judicial manager or liquidator the company’s property, or its books and papers, that the accused is required by law to deliver up (section 234(1)(b));

      • within the 12 months before the judicial management or winding up began, or at any time after: concealing company property or debts; fraudulently removing company property; concealing, destroying or falsifying the company’s books or papers, or making false entries in them; fraudulently altering or omitting anything from the company’s documents; obtaining property on credit for the company by fraud, or under the false pretence that the company is carrying on business, which the company has not paid for; or pawning or disposing of property obtained on credit and not paid for, otherwise than in the ordinary course of business (section 234(1)(c));

      • making a material omission in a statement relating to the company’s affairs (section 234(1)(d));

      • knowing or believing that a false debt has been proved, failing to inform the judicial manager or liquidator within one month (section 234(1)(e));

      • preventing the production of the company’s books or papers (section 234(1)(f));

      • within the same period, attempting to account for company property by fictitious losses or expenses (section 234(1)(g)); and

      • within the same period, making a false representation or committing other fraud to obtain the creditors’ consent to an agreement about the company’s affairs, the judicial management or the winding up (section 234(1)(h)).

    • Section 236 (destroying or falsifying books). The Prosecution must prove:

      • (1) that the accused is an officer or contributory of a company that is in judicial management or is being wound up;

      • (2) that he or she destroyed, mutilated, altered or falsified the company’s books, papers or securities, or made (or was privy to making) a false or fraudulent entry in its registers, books of account or documents; and

      • (3) that he or she did so with intent to defraud or deceive any person.

    • Section 237(1) (failing to keep proper books of account). The Prosecution must prove:

      • (1) that the company is under an investigation under the IRDA, or is in judicial management or is being wound up;

      • (2) that proper books of account were not kept throughout the two years before the investigation, judicial management or winding up began (or, if shorter, the period since the company was incorporated). Books are not proper if they do not explain the company’s transactions and financial position (including day-to-day records of cash received and paid out, and, for a business dealing in goods, records of stock and of goods bought and sold), or if they cannot be conveniently and properly audited (section 237(3)); and

      • (3) that the accused is an officer of the company who is in default.

What defences are available?

The possible defences for each of the offences discussed above are as follows:

  • Fraudulent trading (section 238(4) of the IRDA).

    • Not “knowingly” a party. The accused may contend that he or she did not know of the fraud, and so was not knowingly a party to it. Because knowledge is an element of the offence, the Prosecution must prove it. Whether the contention succeeds turns on what the accused knew at the time, and contemporaneous messages and accounts are usually of considerable weight. In a 2026 High Court appeal (Ng Kuan Chuan v Public Prosecutor [2026] SGHC 5):

      • a director of the brokerage used in a sham foreign exchange investment scheme said that he had been misled into believing that professional traders were trading for investors, and that he had merely followed the founder’s instructions; and

      • the High Court rejected this, because on his own evidence he and a colleague had raised concerns with the founder about the shortfall of funds in the brokerage’s account while the trades were taking place.

    • No fraudulent purpose. The accused may dispute that the company’s business was in fact carried on with intent to defraud creditors, or for a fraudulent purpose. It is not an answer, however, that the company has not been wound up, or that the victims were not creditors of the company (see above).

  • Wrongful trading (section 239(6) of the IRDA).

    • Challenging the elements. The accused may dispute that the company was insolvent when it incurred the debts (or became insolvent as a result of them), or dispute that it had no reasonable prospect of paying them in full (section 239(12) of the IRDA). He or she may also dispute having known that the company was trading wrongfully or, in the case of an officer, that he or she ought in all the circumstances to have known it.

    • A court declaration obtained in advance. A company, or with its consent a person involved in carrying on its business, may apply to the court for a declaration that a particular course of conduct, transaction or series of transactions would not constitute wrongful trading (section 239(10) of the IRDA). Such a declaration is not limited to civil liability. Section 239(10) allows the court to declare that the conduct does not constitute wrongful trading “within the meaning of this section”, and section 239 contains both the civil liability (section 239(1)) and the offence (section 239(6)). A declaration obtained in advance may therefore be relevant to a later charge concerning the same conduct.

    • However, relief from civil liability is not a defence. While the court may relieve a person who acted honestly from personal civil liability for wrongful trading (section 239(2) of the IRDA), there is no equivalent provision for the criminal offence. Matters that might have supported relief under section 239(2) of the IRDA (from personal liability declared under section 239(1)), such as the accused’s honesty, may nonetheless be raised in mitigation (i.e., as factors to reduce the sentence).

  • Offences by officers of companies in judicial management or liquidation (section 234 of the IRDA). Section 234(2) of the IRDA provides two defences, each covering particular offences in section 234(1):

    • No intent to defraud. It is a defence for the accused to prove that he or she had no intent to defraud, where the charge is for failing to disclose the company’s property or how it was disposed of, failing to deliver up the company’s property or books, making a material omission in a statement of the company’s affairs, concealing company property or debts, obtaining property on credit under the false pretence that the company is carrying on business, or pawning or disposing of property obtained on credit and not paid for (section 234(1)(a), (b) and (d), and section 234(1)(c)(i), (vii) and (viii)).

    • No intent to conceal or to defeat the law. It is a defence for the accused to prove that he or she had no intent to conceal the state of affairs of the company or to defeat the law, where the charge is for concealing, destroying or falsifying the company’s books, making false entries in them, or preventing their production (section 234(1)(c)(iii) and (iv), and section 234(1)(f)).

    • The remaining offences. These defences are not available for the other offences in section 234(1), such as fraudulently removing company property, which already require the Prosecution to prove fraud or a false representation. For those offences, the accused may challenge the elements in the usual way.

  • Destroying or falsifying books (section 236 of the IRDA). There is no specific statutory defence. Because the Prosecution must prove an intent to defraud or deceive, the accused may dispute that he or she had that intent, for example where an entry was made in error.

  • Failing to keep proper books of account (section 237(1) of the IRDA). It is a defence for the accused to prove two things: that he or she acted honestly, and that, in the circumstances in which the company’s business was carried on, the failure was excusable (section 237(2)). The accused may also dispute that he or she was an officer in default.