What must the Prosecution prove?

Forgery and falsification of accounts are offences under the Penal Code 1871 (“PC”). There are several forgery and falsification offences. See our page on forgery and falsification offences and their punishment for a full breakdown and explanation of these offences.

For each offence, the Prosecution must prove both the act (i.e., the conduct) and a particular mental state:

  • Forgery (section 465 of the PC). The Prosecution must prove (1) that the accused made a false document within section 464 (broadly, making, signing or altering a document so that it appears to have been made or authorised by someone who did not make or authorise it); and (2) that he or she did so with one of the intents in section 463 (i.e., to cause damage or injury, to support a claim or title, to cause a person to part with property or enter into a contract, or to commit fraud). In the typical case, this means that he or she made or signed the document intending it to be believed that it was made by, or with the authority of, another person. The accused must have known that the other person had not made or authorised it.

  • The more serious forms of forgery (sections 466 to 469 of the PC). In addition to the elements in section 465, the Prosecution must also prove the type of document (for example, a court record, public register, valuable security or receipt) or the purpose of the forgery (to cheat, or to harm a person’s reputation).

  • Using a forged document (section 471 of the PC). The Prosecution must prove (1) that the accused knew or had reason to believe the document was forged; and (2) that he or she used it fraudulently or dishonestly as genuine.

  • Falsification of accounts (section 477A of the PC). The Prosecution must prove:

    • (1) that the accused was a clerk, officer or servant (or acted in that capacity);

    • (2) that the book, record or account belonged to, or was in the possession of, the employer;

    • (3) that the accused intentionally falsified it, or made or helped to make a false entry in it; and

    • (4) that he or she did so with intent to defraud. Under Explanation 1 to section 477A, a general intent to defraud may be alleged, without naming the person to be defrauded or the sum.

In a 2019 decision (Public Prosecutor v Leow Ban Leong and another [2019] SGHC 29), the High Court described the mental state required for section 477A of the PC as having two parts: (1) an intention to deceive, and (2) an intention to gain some advantage or benefit. In that case, a company’s chief executive and a senior manager had prepared documents for onward presentation to the Auditor-General’s Office. The documents were intended to mislead the auditors about the identity of the supplier and the cost of buoys supplied to the Police Coast Guard.

The benefit was that the company could keep an additional $1,000 per buoy under a contract priced at cost plus a margin. The Prosecution had also argued that the accused intended to protect the company’s reputation with the auditors. The court did not need to decide that point, because the financial benefit was enough on its own to establish the intent to defraud.

What defences are available?

The following may provide a defence, or an answer to the charge:

  • Authority. The definition of a false document turns on the absence of authority. A person who signs or completes a document in another’s name, with that person’s authority, does not make a false document. Where documents were prepared in another’s name, disputes about whether authority existed, or was understood to exist within a business, are therefore often central.

  • No intent to defraud. Falsification of accounts requires an intent to defraud, and forgery requires one of the intents listed in section 463 of the PC (to cause damage or injury, to support a claim or title, to cause a person to part with property or enter into a contract, or to commit fraud). Where the advantage intended is so slight that no reasonable person would complain of it, the act is not fraudulent. The threshold is, however, not high. In Leow Ban Leong, the intention to gain a benefit was held to be “clear” because the false documents would have allowed the company to keep the additional charge.

  • Challenging what the falsification was for. Falsifying documents to siphon funds is treated as more serious than falsifying them to hide a failure to follow internal procedures. Where the Prosecution alleges the more serious purpose, it must prove it:

    • In Public Prosecutor v R Shanmugaratnam and another [2026] SGDC 7 (“R Shanmugaratnam”), the Prosecution’s case was that the false escrow confirmation letters had been issued to conceal the true location of the company’s funds, that is, to facilitate or hide a diversion of those funds. The court declined to make that finding. The two persons who could have given that evidence did not testify, and no other evidence was adduced on the point.

    • Nor was it proved that the letters had in fact deceived the company or its auditors, that they had facilitated or concealed a transfer of the funds, or that they had caused the loss of about 1.1 billion euros and the collapse of the group, as alleged.

    • These findings did not lead to an acquittal, because the offence is complete once a false document is made with intent to defraud, and that much was proved. But they reduced the assessment of culpability (i.e., blameworthiness) and harm, because the court sentenced the accused only for what was proved, and not for the more serious purpose (concealing a diversion of funds) and consequences that the Prosecution had alleged.

  • Challenging the elements. The Prosecution must prove each element: (1) who made the document and with what authority, (2) the accused’s capacity (for section 477A of the PC), (3) the intent, and (4) the amount of any loss.

The courts have rejected the following arguments:

  • Acting on another person’s instructions. In Leow Ban Leong, the court held that even if an agent of the customer had instructed the accused to create the false documents, they would still be liable as abettors (i.e., persons who instigate, conspire in or intentionally aid an offence). Acting on instructions may, however, reduce the sentence (see our page on what can reduce a sentence for forgery or falsification of accounts).
  • Using the money to repay sums owed is no excuse. In a 2026 case (Public Prosecutor v Lim Choon Huat (Lin Chunfa) [2026] SGDC 188), the offender claimed that he had made no real gain, because the money went to repay sums he was owed. The claim was rejected: gain includes the recovery of a debt that could not otherwise have been recovered.
  • The company’s own managing director was involved. In Lim Choon Huat, the offender argued that the harm to the company (which was the victim, not an accused) should be treated as less serious because its own managing director was party to the scheme. The argument was rejected entirely: the company is a separate legal person, and the loss also affected its minority shareholders and creditors.
  • A mistaken belief. In another 2026 case (Public Prosecutor v Bernard Tan Wen Sheng [2026] SGDC 61), a doctor claimed that he mistakenly believed he had attended the courses for which he forged certificates. This was held neither to justify nor to reduce the seriousness of the deception.

Can a person outside the company be liable for falsifying its records?

Yes. Section 477A of the PC is directed at clerks, officers and servants (employees), but persons outside the employer’s organisation may be liable for abetting (i.e., instigating, conspiring in or intentionally aiding) the offence. In Lim Choon Huat, the sole director of a supplier issued fictitious and inflated invoices to a customer at the request of the customer’s managing director. He was convicted of abetting, by conspiracy, the falsification of the customer’s records (section 477A read with section 109 of the PC).

Similarly, in Leow Ban Leong, the court held that a person who creates false documents on another’s instructions is liable as an abettor.