What are forgery and falsification of accounts?
Forgery and falsification of accounts are offences under the Penal Code 1871 (“PC”). They are usually charged together with other offences rather than on their own. In corporate cases they usually accompany cheating, criminal breach of trust or corruption. The false document is either the means by which money is obtained or the means by which another wrong is hidden.
“Forgery” is defined in section 463 of the PC as making a false document or electronic record with one of several intents:
- to cause damage or injury to the public or any person;
- to support a claim or title;
- to cause a person to part with property or enter into a contract; or
- to commit fraud.
Section 464 of the PC explains when a person “makes a false document”. Broadly, this is where the person:
- dishonestly or fraudulently makes or signs a document intending it to be believed that it was made by, or with the authority of, a person who did not make or authorise it;
- alters a document in a material part without authority; or
- causes a person to sign a document whose contents that person does not know, because of deception or incapacity.
What are the main offences, and what is the maximum punishment?
The main offences, and the maximum punishment for each, are:
| Offence | Section | Maximum punishment for an individual |
|---|---|---|
| Forgery Making a false document or electronic record with one of the intents described above. | PC s 465 | Imprisonment up to 4 years, a fine, or both |
| Forgery of a court record, public register, official certificate or power of attorney Forging a document that purports to be a court record, a register kept by a public servant (e.g., of births or marriages), a certificate made by a public servant in an official capacity, or a power of attorney. | PC s 466 | Imprisonment up to 10 years; a fine may be added |
| Forgery of a valuable security, will or receipt Forging a document that purports to be a cheque or other valuable security, a will, or a receipt for money or property. | PC s 467 | Imprisonment up to 15 years; a fine may be added |
| Forgery for the purpose of cheating Forgery intending that the false document be used to cheat. | PC s 468 | Imprisonment up to 10 years; a fine may be added |
| Forgery to harm a person’s reputation Forgery intending that the document harm a person’s reputation, or knowing that it is likely to be used for that purpose. | PC s 469 | Imprisonment up to 5 years; a fine may be added |
| Using a forged document as genuine Using as genuine a document the person knows or has reason to believe to be forged. | PC s 471 | The same punishment as if the user had forged the document |
| Possessing a forged document Possessing a document of the kind described in section 466 or 467, knowing it to be forged and intending that it be used as genuine. | PC s 474 | Imprisonment up to 10 years (s 466 documents) or 15 years (s 467 documents); a fine may be added |
| Falsification of accounts A clerk, officer or servant (in modern terms, an employee) who intentionally falsifies the employer’s books, records or accounts, or makes a false entry in them, with intent to defraud. | PC s 477A | Imprisonment up to 10 years, a fine, or both |
There is also a related offence of giving or using a false receipt or account to mislead a principal, under the Prevention of Corruption Act 1960 (see our page on corruption).
When a fine alone is available. Under sections 465 and 477A of the PC, the punishment is imprisonment or a fine, or both, so a fine alone is available. Under sections 466 to 469, the offender “shall be punished with imprisonment … and shall also be liable to fine”. A term of imprisonment must be imposed, and a fine may be added.
Amalgamated charges. Where several acts are combined into one charge (an “amalgamated charge”) under section 124(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 (“CPC”), the offender is liable to up to twice the punishment for a single offence (section 124(8)(a)(ii) of the CPC; see our page on amalgamated charges).
What are the recent changes to the law?
The definition of “fraudulently” (from 1 January 2020)
The Criminal Law Reform Act 2019 inserted a statutory definition of “fraudulently” into the PC with effect from 1 January 2020. A person acts fraudulently if he or she acts with intent to deceive another person and, by means of that deception, intends one of two things:
- that an advantage should come to himself, herself or another person; or
- that a detriment should befall the person deceived or another person.
The advantage or detriment may be temporary or permanent. Where the intended advantage or detriment is so slight that no reasonable person would complain of it, the act is not fraudulent.
The same Act added Explanation 2 to section 477A of the PC. It provides that any books, records, papers, valuable securities or accounts, or any combination of them, form a “set” if they serve the same function or purpose in the employer’s affairs or business. A single charge of falsification may therefore relate to a set of records, rather than to each document separately.
Conduct is charged under the version of the law in force when it took place. A person cannot be punished for conduct that was not an offence when it was done, or more severely than the law then allowed (Article 11(1) of the Constitution). Conduct before 1 January 2020 is therefore charged under the predecessor provisions. The predecessor provisions are usually cited as the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Revised Edition).
What else can follow a conviction?
A conviction for an offence involving fraud or dishonesty punishable with imprisonment for three months or more automatically disqualifies a person from acting as a director (section 154(1)(a)(i) of the Companies Act 1967; see our page on director disqualification). The disqualification lasts for five years from conviction or, if the person is sentenced to imprisonment, for five years after release from prison (section 154(4) of the Companies Act 1967).
Professionals such as doctors, lawyers and accountants may also face disciplinary proceedings before their professional bodies on the same facts.