For a full explanation of forgery and falsification offences in Singapore and the elements required to prove them, see our pages on forgery and falsification offences and their punishment and the elements and defences.

How do the courts decide the sentence?

Forgery and falsification of accounts are offences under the Penal Code 1871 (“PC”). The sentence for falsification of accounts and for forgery is determined by assessing the harm caused and the offender’s culpability, and by comparison with earlier cases. There is no prescribed sentencing framework.

Falsification of accounts: the R Shanmugaratnam approach

The fullest statement of the approach is in Public Prosecutor v R Shanmugaratnam and another [2026] SGDC 7 (“R Shanmugaratnam”), a 2026 District Court decision arising out of the collapse of Wirecard AG. The court’s approach is as follows:

  • Step 1: the court assesses the offender’s culpability (i.e., blameworthiness) and the harm caused.
  • Step 2: it places the case within the full range of punishment for the offence. A fine and/or a short term of imprisonment “may be appropriate where both culpability and harm are assessed to be low”. A substantial term, up to the 10-year maximum, may be considered where both are high.

Factors going to culpability include:

  • the offender’s position and the trust abused;
  • the nature and extent of the falsification;
  • the planning, premeditation and sophistication involved;
  • what the falsification sought to achieve;
  • the underlying reason for the offence, for example “whether it is for personal gain or to comply with a superior’s instruction”; and
  • whether two or more persons acted together, which is generally treated as aggravating (i.e., as increasing the sentence).

Factors going to harm include:

  • whether evidence was destroyed beyond recovery;
  • the actual harm caused;
  • the foreseeable risks to which the company and others were exposed; and
  • whether the victim is a public agency.

In practice, where money was taken, the amount of the loss is used as the main measure of harm. In a 2026 case (Public Prosecutor v Lim Choon Huat (Lin Chunfa) [2026] SGDC 188), the court used the actual loss rather than the higher face value of the false invoices.

How the approach was applied in R Shanmugaratnam itself

The director of a Singapore corporate services company issued letters falsely confirming that his company held more than €1.1 billion of Wirecard’s money in escrow (i.e., held for safekeeping on behalf of the parties to a transaction). A businessman who instigated the letters was convicted with him. Both were convicted after trial.

The court assessed culpability at the higher end of “moderate”. It noted the abuse of a director’s trust, the fabrication of entire documents and the co-ordinated planning, but treated the two accused as followers of the true masterminds. The Prosecution’s case that the letters were issued to hide a diversion of funds, and that they had caused the losses alleged, was not proved.

The director was sentenced to three to five years’ imprisonment per charge, with three sentences running consecutively, for a total of 10 years. The co-accused, in whose case there was no abuse of trust, received a total of six and a half years. Both accused have appealed, and the appeals were pending as at the date of this article.

Forgery and using forged documents: comparable precedents

For forgery and using forged documents, the sentence is likewise determined by the harm and culpability involved and by comparison with earlier cases. Where a forged document is presented to a government agency, general deterrence (i.e., discouraging others from committing similar crimes) is the dominant consideration. In a 1999 decision (Xia Qin Lai v Public Prosecutor [1999] 3 SLR(R) 257), the High Court described such offences as “a fraud on the authorities” requiring a custodial sentence that is “not insubstantial”. In that case, the High Court reduced the sentence for using a forged passport from eight months to four months per charge. By contrast, in a 2021 case (Public Prosecutor v Lee Xiu Qi [2021] SGDC 77), a sentence of seven weeks for forging a letter purportedly issued by the Urban Redevelopment Authority was reduced on appeal to one week, because no gain was made.

Factors personal to the offender

Factors personal to the offender fall on both sides, either aggravating (i.e., increasing the sentence) or mitigating (i.e., reducing the sentence):

  • aggravating: previous convictions, and other charges taken into consideration (i.e., further charges which the offender admits and agrees may be taken into account in sentencing, instead of being tried separately); and
  • mitigating: a plea of guilty, restitution (i.e., paying back the money) and, to a limited extent, a clean record. These are discussed in our page on what can reduce a sentence for forgery or falsification of accounts.

How have the courts applied this approach since?

The table below summarises how the courts have applied this approach in some of the decided cases, and the provision under which each offender was charged.

Type of caseWhat happenedThe takeaway
False invoices used to take money from a company
Abetting falsification of accounts (s 477A)
In a 2026 decision (Public Prosecutor v Lim Choon Huat (Lin Chunfa) [2026] SGDC 188), the director of a logistics company issued fictitious and inflated invoices to a customer over more than three years, at the request of the customer’s managing director. The customer lost about $809,465. He pleaded guilty to three charges of abetting falsification of accounts, with six similar charges taken into consideration.
The court measured harm by the actual loss rather than the higher invoice value, found significant premeditation, treated the resumption of the scheme after it was first discovered as particularly aggravating, and accepted that he was less culpable than the managing director who originated the scheme, but held that his role was indispensable. The total sentence was 18 months’ imprisonment. The offender has appealed against the sentence.
The measure of loss (here the actual loss, not the invoice value), and conduct after the scheme is first discovered, can significantly affect the sentence.
A manager siphoning money through false invoices
Falsification of accounts (s 477A)
In a 2023 decision (Public Prosecutor v Gan Hsiao Ching Elizabeth [2023] SGDC 68), the general manager of a company’s sales division masterminded two conspiracies in which false invoices were used to siphon money from the company, and received $598,342. She faced 157 charges and, after trial, was sentenced to between 7 and 17 months per charge, for sums of about $31,000 to $137,000, and to 52 months in total. The sentence was upheld on appeal.A mastermind convicted after trial on many charges, who abused a position of authority, faces a substantial total sentence.
An outsider issuing sham invoices for a small cut
Forgery (s 465) and falsification of accounts (s 477A)
In a 2017 decision (Public Prosecutor v Kwa Tian Hwa [2017] SGDC 119), a businessman issued 60 fictitious invoices from his businesses to a company at the request of its general manager, who received most of the $2.2 million paid out. The businessman kept about 2.5% of the invoice amounts, about $55,500. Convicted after trial, he received 6 months per charge and 18 months in total, which was upheld on appeal.An outsider who helps an insider take money from a company is liable, but receiving only a small share of the proceeds can keep the sentence lower.
Falsification to hide rather than to take money
Falsification of accounts (s 477A)
Where the falsification hid something rather than took money, the courts have imposed fines or short terms of imprisonment. In the case concerning buoys supplied to the Police Coast Guard (Public Prosecutor v Leow Ban Leong and Foo Fang Liong [2018] SGDC 157), the District Court fined the chief executive $30,000 and the senior manager $15,000 per charge. On the Prosecution’s appeal, the High Court doubled the senior manager’s fines to $30,000 per charge. The chief executive’s fines, which were already the maximum the District Court could then impose, were left as they were. No written judgment was issued on the appeals. In a 2016 case (Public Prosecutor v Chan Siew Lun and others [2016] SGDC 258), where false invoices hid a conflict of interest, the total sentence was four months’ imprisonment.The purpose of the falsification, and whether anyone actually lost money, weigh heavily. Neither of these cases involved money being taken from the employer.
Forged documents submitted to a government agency
Forgery (s 465)
In a 2026 decision (Public Prosecutor v Bernard Tan Wen Sheng [2026] SGDC 61), a doctor applying to the Ministry of Health for a clinic licence submitted scanned certificates of competence for aesthetic procedures, including two for workshops he had never attended. He had made them by pasting his name over his wife’s certificates, and he then told the Ministry that the scans were of original certificates. The Ministry was not in fact deceived, and no patient was harmed.
The court nevertheless held that the custodial threshold (i.e., the point at which imprisonment, rather than a fine, becomes appropriate) was crossed, because the forgery was a “direct assault” on a regulatory framework designed to protect public safety, the steps taken showed premeditation, and he had kept up the lie for nearly three months after being warned. He was sentenced to three months’ imprisonment on each forgery charge and one month for giving false information, a total of four months.
Deceiving a government agency is treated seriously even if the deception fails. But the outcome depends on what the document was for and whether any benefit was obtained: here, a licence to practise on the public, pursued with persistence after a warning.
Falsification alongside cheating or forgery
Falsification of accounts (s 477A), with cheating (s 420) or forgery (s 467)
Where falsification of accounts is charged with cheating or forgery, the overall sentence is often driven by the other charges:
• In a 2018 District Court case (Public Prosecutor v Gene Chong Soon Hui [2018] SGDC 117), a finance manager faced 194 charges of cheating and falsification of accounts for offences committed over eight years, and pleaded guilty to 20 of them. For each of the five falsification charges proceeded with, involving sums of about $47,000 to $85,000, he received eight months’ imprisonment. The total sentence, driven by the cheating charges (four sentences of 33 months running consecutively), was 132 months. It was upheld on appeal.
• In a 2015 case (Public Prosecutor v Noriza binte Aziz [2015] SGDC 157), concerning a law firm secretary, the sentences were four months for each falsification charge and eight months for each charge of forging a valuable security or receipt (section 467 of the PC). The total was 40 months, despite partial restitution.
The overall sentence depends on all the charges brought, not only on the falsification charges.

The cases show that the type of document and the purpose of the falsification produce outcomes ranging from a fine to many years’ imprisonment under the same section.

Can the sentence be a fine?

A fine alone is available for forgery under section 465 and falsification of accounts under section 477A of the PC. It is not available under sections 466 to 469 (forgery of court records, public registers, certificates or powers of attorney; of valuable securities, wills or receipts; for the purpose of cheating; or to harm a person’s reputation), where imprisonment must be imposed.

Whether a fine alone is appropriate depends on the facts of each case. The courts have recognised that it may be appropriate in some cases, for example:

  • Where the falsification hid something rather than took money. Fines of $30,000 per charge were the final outcome for a chief executive and a senior manager who prepared false documents for auditors (Public Prosecutor v Leow Ban Leong and Foo Fang Liong [2018] SGDC 157; the senior manager’s fines were increased to that level on the Prosecution’s appeal).
  • Where no wrongful gain or loss was intended. A fine of $10,000 per charge was imposed for falsified payment vouchers used to reduce a modest tax liability (Public Prosecutor v Pang Wah [2010] SGDC 505). A fine was also imposed for forged bills of lading submitted for rebates to which the offender was in any event entitled (Public Prosecutor v Teng Siong Wei [2009] SGDC 465).
  • Where a fine is high enough to deter. A deterrent sentence “need not always take the form of a custodial sentence”, and may be a fine if it is high enough, as the High Court held in 2004 (Public Prosecutor v Cheong Hock Lai and other appeals [2004] 3 SLR(R) 203).

Where an employer has been deprived of money, or a public regulatory framework has been undermined, imprisonment has been warranted and imposed. A defence submission for fines was rejected both in Bernard Tan Wen Sheng and, for the co-accused who instigated the letters, in R Shanmugaratnam.